AI Wins › Time & money saved
A couple used AI to help get a $22,604 surprise ER bill waived
High verification: Named people in New York Times reporting by Sarah Kwon, with a hospital spokesperson confirming a clerical error and the waiver. How we check stories
What happened
Sarah Kwon reported for The New York Times1 on April 8, 2026 (also carried by The Seattle Times2) that Davalos, then 34, was treated at George Washington University Hospital in Washington, D.C., after a fall. She said she never got a bill. Two years later a collections agency said she owed about $22,604. Records, according to the Times, had incorrectly listed her as uninsured.
The couple first disputed the bill with the hospital's parent company, Universal Health Services. Kerr said that removed one medication charge but left the rest. In July 2025 he uploaded the billing and medical records to Claude and asked whether they had further options. Claude suggested several arguments, including that the hospital might have missed legal requirements about debt and insurance. Kerr told the Times that for the first time he felt "we might actually win."
Using many of those points, he wrote to executives at the hospital and Universal Health Services. Shortly after, the hospital waived the entire bill. Susan LaRosa, a hospital spokesperson, told the Times a "clerical error" had been made at admission and that the debt was dropped once the hospital had the updated information; Davalos's credit was not affected. Universal Health Services said the debt was eliminated after it had all the information and finished talking with the patient.
What the AI got wrong
The Times asked Ariel Levinson-Waldman, founding president of the nonprofit legal-aid group Tzedek DC, to review a summary of the dispute. He said some of Claude's analysis was right, but the chatbot misunderstood the debt and insurance laws it cited and missed other options the couple might have had. Some rules Claude pointed to apply to insurers or collectors, not hospitals.
Kwon's piece also shows how uneven these fights can be. Other patients she spoke with got little help from chatbots, or found the advice confusing. Kerr later tried helping others with the same approach; some gave up, and he told the Times that success often needs persistence "AI can't solve for you."
Why this matters if you're choosing an AI plan
- A mid-priced (or even free) chatbot can help you read dense bills and draft a clear letter, but you still do the pushing.
- Named journalism with a hospital on the record is rarer and more useful than a viral self-report.
- AI can sound confident and still misstate the law, so treat it as a drafting aid, not your lawyer.
Credits. Reporting by Sarah Kwon for The New York Times, also published via The Seattle Times. Subjects: Jackie Davalos and Walter Kerr. Legal commentary in the Times by Ariel Levinson-Waldman (Tzedek DC). Hospital comment by Susan LaRosa (George Washington University Hospital); Universal Health Services comment by Maria English. Anthropic declined to comment to the Times on Claude's performance in this case. Up to Speed with AI has no relationship with the people or companies named, and nothing here suggests they endorse us or any AI plan.
Spotted an error, or are you in this story and want something changed? Tell us and we'll fix or remove it.
More AI wins
One developer, one AI model, and free look-alikes of Photoshop, Premiere and Excel
A veteran engineer used Claude to build free, open-source stand-ins for Adobe and Microsoft Office apps. Real and downloadable, but early alpha.
A 23-year-old amateur used AI to help crack a 60-year-old math problem
An amateur gave an unsolved Erdős problem to GPT-5.4 Pro. Terence Tao and Jared Duker Lichtman checked the proof and say the key idea is new.
A family says a $20 AI plan helped cut a $195,000 hospital bill to about $33,000
A grieving family used Claude to decode billing codes, flag duplicate charges and write dispute letters. Self-reported, so read it that way.
A tech writer built his own stand-ins for $400 a year of app subscriptions, using a $20 AI plan
How-To Geek's Dibakar Ghosh used Claude to build home-made swaps for a grammar checker, a dictation app and a time tracker. Real savings, with a few catches.